Polly is one of three executors of husband Timothy's will¹⁰⁶⁴ , the others being James Congdon Goble and Truman L Goble. The heirs listed for that will are: James C Goble, son; Truman S Goble, son; Solomon A Goble, son; Mary Ann (Goble) Barkley, daughter; Franklin Barkley, son-in-law; Ruth Goble, daughter; Sally Goble, daughter; Nancy Goble, daughter; and Eliza Jane Goble, daughter.

In 1850, following her husband's death the previous year, Polly is living with "Freeman" Goble in Bradford, along with her daughters Ruth, Sally, Nancy and Eliza J Goble. It is assumed that "Freeman" is her son Truman, as James Goble and Solomon Goble are immediate neighbors.